Amazon Ad

Monday, March 3, 2014

Dallas (TNT Series): Good news, Everybody! The Ewings are back, and they are more scandalous than ever before (My thoughts on episode 3x01 “The Return”)



Right off the bat, I’d like to say that I found the season three premiere somewhat challenging to review. That’s not because I thought the season premiere was bad, it’s actually a very good episode in my opinion. What makes this episode particularly challenging for me to review is the fact that I feel like this episode was primarily providing exposition for season three instead of simply diving right into the action and having the show hit the ground running like the writers did with the season two premiere.

I don’t view that as a bad thing at all though. My main complaint with the season two premiere was actually that even for a show that typically moves at a pretty fast pace, the season two premiere seemed to move too quickly for its own good, especially when it comes to how they handled the reveal of Ann’s secret and how it effected Sue Ellen’s life as well. Because the writers seemed to be moving really fast with the events that took place in the season two premiere, as a viewer I felt like I wasn’t being given a chance to take everything in and process what was happening from an emotional standpoint, which was a little frustrating at times and was one of the contributing factors in terms of why I found the reveal of Ann’s secret so underwhelming and disappointing. There was also the fact that Ann’s secret was simply just rather lame. However, Brenda Strong’s acting in that episode as well as season two as a whole definitely helped make up for the lameness regarding the details of Ann’s past that were revealed last season, but I digress.

In terms of my thoughts on the season three premiere itself, I found it refreshing that the writers really used the entire season premiere to move forward from the events of the season two finale and set things up for season three. One of the things that I was really glad to see was the fact that the writers specifically established how much time had passed since the events of the season finale unlike the season two premiere where they played fast and loose with how they handled the passage of time. For example, Ewing Energies was completely up and running and yet Pamela was no longer visibly pregnant. However, I just wrote off the whole thing with Pamela not looking pregnant for roughly the first third of the season as something the writers did since John Ross and Pamela had several romantic scenes during that portion of the season. However, while they did a mini time jump in this episode, they did start out the episode by picking up right where they left off with John Ross and Emma meeting with each other at a hotel so that Emma could give John Ross some files that belonged to Harris, followed by them having sex. After the theme song, the show jumped ahead twelve hours.



Despite the fact that John Ross is married to Pamela now, it looks like he fully intends to carry on an affair with Emma. Based on Emma’s behavior throughout the episode, it looks like Emma is much more infatuated with John Ross than he is with her though. It seemed like she was the one who was initiating most of their hookups throughout the episode. While John Ross and Emma were carrying on their affair, Sue Ellen has decided that since John Ross and Pamela got married at a wedding chapel in Las Vegas, she wants to throw them another big wedding at Southfork so the whole family can see John Ross and Pamela get married. John Ross also gave Pamela what’s definitely the hugest diamond ring that I’ve ever seen and proposed to her again at the beginning of the episode.

I have to say that as a huge Jebecca fan, I loved the scene where John Ross proposed to Pamela. I especially liked Josh Henderson’s acting in that scene and the episode as a whole. John Ross really came across as being J.R.’s son when it comes to Josh’s acting in that scene, but I’m getting off track here. Anyway, Sue Ellen is now working with Pamela and Ann to help plan John Ross and Pamela’s wedding, and to make the whole situation with John Ross cheating on Pamela with Emma more awkward, Emma also joined in on helping with the wedding preparations at one point in the episode.

As I said earlier, I feel like this episode primarily served as exposition for season three, and at times I felt like the writers were foreshadowing to certain events that could potentially happen later on in the season. For example, at one point in the episode Sue Ellen mentioned the fact that Kristin Shepard, who’s Christopher’s biological mother, ended up dead in the swimming pool at Southfork ranch in the season four finale of the original series. I can’t help but wonder if that was the writers’ way of hinting at the possibility that Emma is going to end up dead in the swimming pool during a fight with either John Ross or Pamela at the end of season three, if not sooner.

While I admit that I wasn’t too crazy about Emma when she was first introduced last season, she did grow on me as season two continued, but I wouldn’t be too terribly devastated if the writers killed her off since I’ve often found her rather irritating at times. Thankfully, she’s not as irritating and insufferable as Christopher has proved to be. If Emma somehow managed to annoy me as much as Christopher has throughout the series that would definitely be one for the record books. Regardless of how much Emma may annoy me at times, there’s also a part me that would hate to see Emma get killed off. I say this only because Harris and his mother, Judith, kept Emma from Ann for years, and it wasn’t all that long ago that Ann was reunited with Emma. I would feel pretty bad for Ann if she lost Emma all over again so soon after they were reunited with each other.

Speaking of Christopher, given the fact that last season I found him to be 1,000X more annoying than he was in season one, I was definitely worried that Cynthia Cidre and the rest of the writers would manage to somehow find a way to make him even more annoying this season. That being said, Christopher didn’t annoy me nearly as much in this episode as he did 99.9% of the time last season. One of the only things that Christopher did in this episode that truly annoyed me were the fact that he/Jesse Metcalfe has grown a full-on beard, which looks beyond gross. I don’t know if it was Jesse’s decision to grow a beard, or if it was storyline dictated since Cynthia Cidre did talk about the fact that Christopher has grown a beard and will keep the beard for a while this season in a recent interview that she did to talk about season three.

Personally, I didn’t think that Jesse could pull off having a soul patch last season without it looking repulsive and ridiculous, and he definitely can’t make having a beard look attractive either. However, in Jesse’s defense, men having lots of facial hair has often been a major turn-off for me personally and in most cases makes men seem less attractive in my eyes. Maybe that makes me sound incredibly shallow, but I very rarely think that facial hair actually makes a man look sexy, but that’s just how I feel.

The other thing that Christopher did in this episode that annoyed me was his apology to Elena for the way he treated her in the season two finale. I know that I should just be glad that this was one of the rare cases where Christopher had the decency to apologize for his behavior, but that scene just made him seem beyond stupid and completely lacking in self-awareness. The reason why I feel he came across as being really stupid was the fact that from what I could tell, he failed to see that he has a pattern of acting and talking impulsively, which usually ends with him acting like an irrational asshole, especially when it comes to how he treats Elena or Pamela. The only thing that kind of saved that scene was the fact that Elena didn’t exactly forgive him for his behavior and told him that they both need to work through their own personal issues before they even think about getting back together.

They briefly introduced Christopher’s new love interest Heather, who’s played by AnnaLynne McCord, and as a fan of AnnaLynne’s acting, I have to say that I loved what they showed of Heather. Heather is definitely the polar opposite of Naomi Clarke, AnnaLynne’s character on 90210. Heather is a ranch hand, and based on the spoilers I’ve read, it sounds like Heather is also a single mother. I hate to say it, but the writers have finally found a way to make me be at least somewhat interested in Christopher’s storyline by casting AnnaLynne as his new love interest. In the past the writers have constantly given me one reason after the other to mock Christopher and Jesse Metcalfe’s horrific acting, so I’ve never really been able to actually enjoy Christopher’s scenes apart from gleefully cackling in contempt at Christopher’s constant misfortune.

For those who might not remember, season two ended with Elena going to meet a man named Joaquin after Christopher kicked her to the curb after discovering the fact that she helped Drew leave town when he was in trouble with the law for blowing up the rig, which ultimately led to the death of his and Pamela’s unborn babies. Plus, she also discovered that J.R. had switched the deeds when her father bought the Henderson’s land. Basically, when J.R. switched the deed to the land that Elena’s father had planned to drill on, Elena’s father got a worthless piece of land that that he had tried in vain for years to drill for oil on, while J.R. got the land that was rich in oil.

I personally liked Elena’s thinking when she agreed to be Cliff Barnes’ proxy. She told him that given what the Ewings’ did to her father and the fact that Sue Ellen took her shares in Ewing Energies, forcing her out of the company that she had helped start, helping him wasn’t about getting revenge in her eyes, it was about getting justice for her family. After all, she mentioned that while Ewings’ will always protect each other, they are also not afraid to screw other people over to get what they want, which I think is kind of true. Just ask Cliff Barnes.

My main concern with this storyline is that I have no idea how the writers will be able to justify keeping Elena around once Christopher, Bobby and the others eventually discover what she’s up to. This whole thing could very well lead to them turning against her once and for all, and the show is about their family, so if that were to happen it might be tricky for the writers to give Elena a purpose for still being a part of the show when the entire Ewing family could end up making her a pariah. Plus, I’ve always felt that Elena could be rather self-righteous at times in the past, so I have no idea how she will ever be able to act like she has any moral high ground with them in the future. Although, this is a soap opera and characters doing the kind of thing that Elena is doing right now on other soap operas usually doesn’t stop them from acting like they have the moral high ground with others.

As for how the writers and Jordana Brewster are handling this storyline, I’m liking it so far. I feel like Jordana should have some kind of mischievous smile on her face at times depending on what she’s doing or what’s happening in certain scenes though. When it comes to actors portraying this kind of storyline, most actors usually give a mischievous smile at times on shows like the original Dallas and the new Dallas, Revenge or various daytime soap operas. Instead, Jordana just spent most of the episode scowling and looking like she was mad. It just felt rather off-putting to watch at times. I also felt the way Elena showed up at Southfork to apologize for everything that happened with Drew last season was rather weird. It looked like Jordana just wandered onto the set without any idea of what the hell she was supposed to do. It was probably just bad blocking for the scene though, which I’m guessing was the director’s responsibility. Her entrance into the scene where she came to Ewing Global to ask for a job felt much more natural, and I feel like Jordana wearing glasses during her scenes at Ewing Global and the music they used to the score the scene where Elena was looking at business documents on the computer helped give Elena a schemer vibe, which was nice to see.

One of the questions that I found myself having before the season started was how the writers could possibly make Elena’s storyline with her trying to get revenge justice for what Ewings did to her father work from the get-go. I didn’t think that Elena could just come back and announce to everybody that she’s now Cliff Barnes’ proxy for the part of Barnes Global that he still possesses. However, it turns out that’s what addition of both Juan Pablo Di Pace and his character, Nicolas Treviño, to the show is for. Nicolas is a wealthy self-made business man who showed up at Ewing Global to announce that he was Cliff Barnes’ proxy just as John Ross, Bobby, Sue Ellen, Christopher and Pamela were discussing their plans to sell the consumer division of Barnes Global. He informed them that they basically don’t have super majority over the company, but he does, which means he can block the sale of the consumer division that they had been planning to sell. This news left everybody scrambling the find a way to get the money that they would have gotten from selling the consumer division, because the company needs the money. At the end of the episode, Elena went back to Joaquin’s pace, and it was revealed that Nicolas Treviño is Joaquin. Basically, it sounds like he’s going to be the face of Elena’s plan to get revenge justice for her family while she pulls the strings.

This reveal also raised a question that I always had about Revenge and the fact that the Grayson’s never recognized that Emily Thorne was actually Amanda Clarke. Sure, she was a child when they last saw her and she returned to the Hamptons as an adult, but I always thought that they would have at least recognized to her to a certain degree. Anyway, it’s basically the same thing with Nicolas. It seems weird to me that they didn’t think that Nicolas looked kind of familiar when he showed up at Ewing Global. After all, they established at the beginning of the series that Elena has known the Ewing family since she was a child. In this episode, they established that she has known Nicolas ever since they were children and he still went by the name Joaquin, so if that were the case I can’t help but think that John Ross, Christopher and the rest of the Ewing family would have probably also met him back then too. Nicolas mentioned that Elena’s father had essentially adopted him and raised him as a son, although not in a legal sense from what I understood, so that’s either a plot hole, or it’s something that I really hope the writers clarify in a later episode.

I know they only showed Nicolas a little bit in this episode, but I felt like Juan Pablo Di Pace did a really good job in this episode. Apparently, Cynthia Cidre and the other producers had been having a really hard time finding the right actor for the role until they saw his audition. That being said, I feel like both Juan and his character Nicolas Treviño are going to be a fantastic addition to the show.

The whole storyline with Elena seeking revenge justice isn’t the only storyline that I’m having a hard time picking a side with. Now that John Ross owns half the deed Southfork, he’s planning to do a big remodel of the house. Naturally, Bobby is completely against the idea, saying that John Ross doesn’t respect their family’s history. What makes it hard for me to completely side with Bobby or completely side with John Ross is that on the one hand, sometimes I feel like at some point Bobby simply decided that he’s going to always be against anything John Ross does or wants to do. Also, sometimes I feel like Bobby comes across as being so stuck in the past and stuck on the idea of honoring Miss Ellie’s wishes that he’s unable to accept that change is an inevitable part of life. Plus, sometimes Bobby’s behavior makes him come across as a major momma’s boy to the point where it’s a bit extreme and rather creepy when you consider the fact that Miss Ellie has been dead for years. Usually I think of the idea of someone being a momma’s boy as something that men would grow out of at some point, or that they at least cease being a momma’s boy once their mother has died.

Plus, I’ve always thought that it was really weird that Bobby frequently says that he thinks John Ross doesn’t respect their family’s legacy when John Ross wants to continue to focus the family business on the oil industry like their family has for several generations while Bobby seems to have no problem with Christopher’s beliefs that oil as an energy source is a thing of the past. If anything, I feel like Christopher is disrespecting their family’s legacy by being so pro methane and so anti-oil, but you never hear Bobby accuse Christopher of not respecting their family’s history. (Sighs heavily)

That being said, in Bobby’s defense, a part of me thinks that maybe John Ross is planning to remodel Southfork simply because he knew it would piss Bobby off and he’s letting the fact that he now owns half the deed to Southfork go to his head. Like I said, I’m having a hard time deciding whom to side with in this particular situation.

Mitch Pileggi wasn’t in this episode very much, but Harris was released from prison towards the end of the episode. As for how he got out of prison and who got him out of jail, I have no idea. For some reason I have feeling that Nicolas arranged to have him released from prison as a part of Elena’s plan to get revenge justice for her family. It’s definitely not any of the Ewings, and with Cliff in prison, it wouldn’t make sense for him to be able to do that, so Nicolas seems to be the most logical guess. The only other person that would make sense to me would be Emma given John Ross’ line earlier in the episode about Emma now having more power than she probably realizes. I could be wrong about who got Harris out of jail though.

I think it would be wrong of me if I didn’t address the new opening credits for the show. While they still show footage of various parts of Dallas like they did in the first two seasons of the show, the credits now resemble the opening credits for the original series where they did the split screen effect, showing footage of three clips of each cast members. Based on the interviews that Cynthia Cidre has done for season three that I have read at this point, it sound like they will really be embracing the somewhat campy nature that the original series seemed to have. Personally, I think changing the opening credits to resemble the credits for the original series is a great way to honor the original series and reflect the idea that they appear to be embracing certain qualities that the original series had, which they didn’t necessarily embrace in the first two seasons. I’m not saying that as a criticism of the show, I’m just making an observation.

Originally I had hope to have finished and posted my review of season two as a whole before season three started, but due a number of reasons, I’m still finishing it up. As I was watching each episode again, I decided to pick one, or in some cases two or three moments involving Christopher to be his biggest face-palming moment or moments of the episode. Like I said earlier, he didn’t annoy me as much in this episode compared to how much he has annoyed me in the past, but he still managed to annoy me in this episode. As silly as my selection of Christopher’s biggest face-palming moment for this episode may be, it’s the fact that Christopher grew a beard. There are so many ridiculous things about that, such as the time frame between the end of season two and this episode being way too short for Christopher to have gone from having a soul patch to having a fully grown beard. Plus, there’s also the fact that Jesse Metcalfe simply looks hideous with a beard. I don’t know if it was strictly a storyline decision, Jesse simply wanting to grow beard, or if it was a joint decision, but the beard was definitely a huge mistake.

All things considered, this episode really did feel like it was serving as exposition for the season. I feel like the writers really did a great job of setting things up for season three. The writing for this episode was really great, and I love the direction that Cynthia Cidre and the rest of the writers seem to be taking the show in this season based on the season premiere alone. While I’m excited about Elena’s storyline and the addition of both Juan Pablo Di Pace and his character Nicolas Treviño, I do think Jordana Brewster’s acting for this storyline could use a little tweaking.

Josh Henderson continued to really shine in the role of John Ross, and his scenes were definitely one of the biggest highlights of the episode for me personally, especially when it comes to the scene where John Ross proposed to Pamela. I’d be lying if I said that I hadn’t been a little worried about what the show would be like since this will be the first season of the show that’s 100% J.R./Larry Hagman free going into the season, but watching this episode really helped me get rid of those fears since while he may be dead, they still continued acknowledge the legacy of J.R. in this episode, which was wonderful. This episode really left me feeling like the viewers can expect an amazing third season.

That being said, my final score for this episode is 9 out of 10. 




No comments :